Asphalt Shingle, Metal, and Tile: Which Roofing Material Is Best For Your Winter Park Home

Roof replacement is one of the best investments you can make to keep your Winter Park home going strong. Your roof protects you from the elements, but it does much more. It is responsible for ensuring that the rest of the building is safe and secure.

In Central Florida, a new roof will improve your home inside and out. Your roof is the biggest contributor to the airflow cycle in your structure. Hot air should naturally flow upward and escape the house – it should never get stuck due to an aging roof or attic.

With a sound new roof, air flows more effectively and your whole property benefits as a result.

You end up with:

  • Warmer temperatures in the winter without having to run your heater constantly
  • Cooler temperatures in the summer with fewer on-off cycles in your air conditioner
  • More attic-level air flow, which prevents heat damage to the bottom of your roof
  • Significant savings on your energy bill and much less household energy consumption

No matter what kind of roof you choose for your Winter Park home, a combination of high-quality roof materials and the best installation will deliver these benefits. That said, each roofing product has its own benefits you may wish to consider before you make a final decision.

There are three different roofing options popular with Central Florida homeowners. We’re confident you will find one of them is the ideal choice for you. While you can always get the facts direct from your roofing team at Sheegog Contracting, we know many people enjoy doing the research themselves.

Let’s take a look at the most sought after roofing options in Winter Park and what makes them special.

Asphalt Shingle: A Reliable and Beloved Selection Common Throughout Central Florida

The asphalt shingle roof is the most common in Florida and is very popular throughout much of the United States. Pretty much everyone is familiar with a shingle roof, but today’s high-quality asphalt shingles offer a variety of improvements over homes where you may have grown up.

Let’s zoom in on the benefits of asphalt shingle roofs in Central Florida:

1. Price

As a general rule, the asphalt shingle roof is cost-effective. These shingles can usually offer you the lowest cost per square foot – so, the bigger your roof is, the more you will tend to save. This is great if you want to get things done quickly without saving up for long or financing a bigger project.

The savings aren’t limited to the initial installation, either. Roof repair on a shingle roof is very simple and straightforward. Damaged shingles are removed and new shingles of a similar style and construction are put in their place. That’s inexpensive and fast, ideal when you’re racing against storm damage.

2. Straightforward Maintenance

A shingle roof lasts for anywhere from 20 to 30 years depending on your maintenance schedule and the weather events it is subject to. When it comes to keeping your roof in good shape, your role in the process is very simple: Keep the gutters clean and watch out for signs of damage after rough weather.

It’s a wise idea to have your Winter Park shingle roof inspected once a year. The best time to do this is at least a month before the start of storm season, so you have time to do any repair work you might need. Remember, water damage can weaken your roof without leaving much evidence. Let a pro check it out!

3. Low Environmental Impact

Old-fashioned shingles used to end up in landfills, but this is no longer the case. With every new generation of shingles, manufacturers are using more post-consumer products in their composition. Changes in the manufacturing process have ensured that more shingles can be recycled. 100% recycled shingles are new to the market, but there is every reason to believe that they will soon become commonplace.

4. High Degree of Customization

Asphalt shingles are available in virtually any color you can name. While only a certain selection can be had off the shelf, it’s easy to put in an order for custom colors through your Central Florida roofing team. Your creative vision can come to life, complete with the execution that brings it all together.

Asphalt shingles are highly versatile in ways you might not expect. They can be customized to simulate a full spectrum of different materials. They can also add dimensionality and heft to your roof. Shingles designed with this in mind are called “dimensional” and can upgrade your architectural look.

Residential Metal Roofing: A Unique and Highly Durable Contender with High Performance

When you want something that will turn your ideas about roofing upside down, it’s time for residential metal roofing in Central Florida. Metal roofing is like nothing else available on the market today and has some unique benefits that appeal to today’s homeowners.

If you’ve lived in Central Florida all your life, you’ve probably seen metal roofing before, but never like it is today. For decades, metal roofs were used on barns, grain silos, and other agricultural buildings. This is what many people are expecting from metal roofs, but it couldn’t be further from the case.

The kind of metal roof you get on your home is something else entirely.

Here’s why so many people in Central Florida are now choosing metal for their roof replacement:

1. Metal Is One of the Longest Lasting Residential Roofs of Them All

You’ve already heard that you can expect about 20 to 30 years of service from your shingle roof. But if you are looking for a roof that will stand the test of time – one you can pass on to the kids and they can pass on, too – you may be looking for a residential metal roof instead.

A residential metal roof should generally last at least 50 years. That said, it can last 80 years or even more. There are many different reasons for this. First and foremost, the material is just more durable. Secondly, the roof’s design supports and reinforces the fasteners, which are a structural weak point.

One thing that makes metal amazing is how well it stands up to weather. Rain runs right off. Wind uplift is rare. Metal roofs are highly resistant to mold, mildew, pest incursion, and even fire. And contrary to a popular myth, metal roofs are not more likely than others to be struck by lightning.

2. A Metal Roof Requires Much Less Maintenance Than Most Others

One of the reasons a metal roof stands out is that it does not really require much maintenance in order to get the outstanding longevity that you can realistically expect from it. Instead of inspecting it once a year as you would a shingle roof, it is usually safe to inspect it every other year.

No matter what kind of weather you face up to in Central Florida, almost any impact on your metal roof will be superficial. That is, a small or even medium-sized dent will usually have no effect on the roof’s performance. If one metal sheet gets damaged, it can be replaced, leaving the rest intact.

If there is one drawback to the metal roof, it’s the fact that some of them don’t account for the potential problems with snow accumulation and snowmelt on the roof. Luckily, this is the last problem you will ever need to worry about in Central Florida!

3. Your Metal Roof Can Help You Save Money on Your Electric Bill

The right residential metal roof can deliver incredible savings on your electric bill. This is a big deal for residents of Winter Park and people all throughout Florida. It is not uncommon to see the electric bill go up by $100 or even more in the summer, so every penny of savings counts.

When it comes to metal roofing, the power of savings is in the improvement in indoor airflow as above. But the even bigger component is how incredibly reflective metal roofing is. A light-colored metal roof that has been installed properly can reflect 50% of the solar radiation that strikes it.

With less solar energy penetrating the structure, it becomes much easier for the air conditioning to meet your needs without running all day long or cycling on and off constantly. Cycling, in particular, pulls an enormous amount of energy and accelerates mechanical wear on your air conditioning compressor.

But the loss of that extra sunlight does not mean you’ll be cold. Far from it!

With air flowing freely throughout the home, you will actually be cooler in the summer and warmer in the winter. Naturally, though, winter doesn’t always show up on time here in Central Florida – so the effect in cold weather is not as noticeable as it might be in coastal areas.

Tile Roofing: Ideal for Central Florida’s Mission-Style Homes and Many More

If you’ve explored Florida, you’ve probably seen examples of stunning clay tile roofs or concrete tile roofs. Red clay tiles roofs, in particular, are associated with the Mission style that was brought to the state by some of the earliest Spanish pioneers. Although it is more common in the southern part of the state, there are many memorable examples here in Central Florida as well.

Even if your home has a completely different style, you should still think about the benefits of tile:

1. As One of the Heaviest Roofing Materials, Tile Is Nearly Immune to Wind Uplift

Wind uplift has the potential to be the most serious problem that can strike a roof in Florida. No matter how carefully installed or well-constructed a roof is, your interior will be at the mercy of the elements if wind uplift happens. The vacuum pressure caused by uplift can effectively rip the roof completely off.

Successive changes in Florida’s building codes have made wind uplift less likely, but it can still happen. A shingle roof is at the greatest risk, followed by a residential metal roof. Clay tile roofs are the heaviest roofing material most people will consider, so they are nearly immune to this problem.

Concrete tile is generally lighter than clay tile and is used as an alternative for homes that cannot bear the extra weight. Still, it is an extremely sturdy material that’s highly resistant against cracks and performs strongly against Florida weather. Plus, tile has the potential to last the longest out of any of the common roofing materials: It could go on for as long as a century with some basic maintenance.

2. Tile Roofs Have Aesthetic Properties No Other Florida Roof Can Match

When you are comparing tile options, you’ll usually be looking at clay or concrete. These are familiar materials that do not require you to pay a luxurious premium. Yet, the best tile around can easily be made to look like the most lavish materials, such as marble, that would often be prohibitively expensive.

A tile roof is also exceptional when it comes to crafting the exact slope of the roof and accentuating any architectural features you might want to draw attention to. The classic look of clay tile creates a sort of ripple effect that is fascinating to look at and will weather exceptionally well over the years.

If you are not a big fan of the dark red color associated with clay tile, that’s no barrier to having the beautiful tile roof you want. Like many other roofs, roofing tiles have been made available in a growing range of colors. You can even combine different colors for a gradient if you wish. The essential piece of the puzzle is to select a Winter Park roofer you can trust.

No Matter What Roof You Choose in Winter Park, Sheegog Contracting Makes It Easy

A roof replacement is a big decision, so we want to make it as easy for you as possible.

No matter if you choose Sheegog Contracting or the other guys, we’re dedicated to ensuring you can make an informed decision. Our proven five-step process is intended to make things simple. You will always know exactly what you’re getting, when, and how.

If it turns out you don’t need a full replacement, we’ll stick by you every step of the way through roof repair that will extend the life of your existing roof. We can also provide you with annual or semi-annual Central Florida roof inspections to help your home weather the Atlantic hurricane season.

Throughout our years in the industry, we understand that many homeowners are intimidated by the whole process of getting a roof replaced. They wonder if they will really receive the value they want. This problem is compounded by the prevalence of roofing scams every summer.

Sheegog Contracting stands head and shoulders over the rest as a team you can trust.

As a BBB-accredited business with an A+ rating, we work hard to honor the trust you place in us. That means high quality, responsive customer service, and treating your property with respect from the start of your process to the finish. We value your time and want to be your roofing team of choice.

Check Google and you will find we have earned a stellar 4.8 out of 5 rating. We also have a 4.8 out of 5 on Facebook reviews and a 4.7 on GAF. Our team is honored to be certified as GAF Master Elite Roofers. That means we can get every ounce of performance out of GAF roofing products. We even have a 5 out of 5 on Angi, formerly Angie’s List, one of the largest websites for reviewing contractors in the world.

Of course, you shouldn’t have to make your decision based on what you see on any website.

The best way to sort out which Winter Park roofer is the best one for you is to give them a call. You should always get full, substantive answers to your questions that give you the confidence to move forward. If a contractor is evasive or something “just doesn’t feel right,” always look elsewhere.

Our team is ready and waiting to hear from you. Contact us to find out more or get started.


We give our clients transparency, efficiency & quality workmanship.


Submit the form to get your FREE QUOTE

Get our free guide:
4 Things to Ask Your Roofing Contractor

Lead source tree

start your free quote

Fill out the form, and we will be in touch shortly.

Book Your Free
Roof Inspection Today!

Instructions: All you have to do is fill in the fields, click the next button and you will move to the next page.  Once completed, click “SEND” and your information will be sent to us in seconds.  Expect a text message from one of our Customer Success Representatives to begin coordinating your support.

Get $150 Toward Your Roof Replacement!

Click below, limited time only.